Expertise: When Knowledge Becomes Judgment
By Robert Knakal November 17, 2026 10:05 am
reprints
Over the past several weeks, I have had the privilege of delivering keynote speeches about what I call “The DNA of Success,” a framework built around five characteristics that I believe are essential to achieving extraordinary results: passion, discipline, curiosity, expertise and becoming.
In my previous three columns, I explored passion, which provides the fuel for achievement; discipline, which converts enthusiasm into consistent action; and curiosity, which transforms experience into learning. The fourth characteristic, expertise, is where those first three characteristics begin to compound into something extraordinary.
Expertise is not simply knowing more than other people. It is developing the ability to recognize patterns, understand complexities, anticipate consequences, and make better decisions, particularly when the answers are not obvious.

In a world where information is becoming increasingly accessible, this distinction has never been more important. Knowledge is knowing what the facts are. Expertise is understanding what those facts mean. Judgment is knowing what to do about them.
I have been selling investment properties in New York City since July 16, 1984. Over those 42-plus years, I have personally participated in the sale of more than 2,428 buildings with an aggregate value exceeding $25 billion. Those numbers represent an enormous amount of experience, but experience alone does not create expertise. What matters is what you do with that experience.
Every transaction presents an opportunity to learn something about human behavior, market dynamics, negotiation, valuation, or the countless variables that influence outcomes. Some lessons come from successful transactions. Others come from deals that fall apart, assumptions that prove incorrect, or decisions that produce unexpected consequences.
The challenge is to turn those individual experiences into a deeper understanding of how things work. Experience gives you the raw material. Curiosity extracts the lessons. Discipline allows you to apply them repeatedly. Expertise is what emerges from that process over time.
One of the most fascinating aspects of expertise is the ability to recognize things that others might not even notice. Consider two brokers evaluating the same development site. Both have access to the zoning regulations, comparable sales, construction costs, financing assumptions and projected condominium prices. Both can build sophisticated financial models. Yet they may arrive at dramatically different conclusions about the property’s value. Why? Because the numbers are only part of the equation.
An experienced development site specialist may recognize that a particular configuration creates unusual construction challenges, that a seemingly insignificant zoning provision offers an opportunity, or that the depth of the buyer pool for a specific product type is changing. These insights are rarely found in a spreadsheet. They come from years of studying transactions, speaking with market participants, understanding the motivations of buyers and sellers, and observing how theoretical assumptions translate into actual market behavior.
The difference between information and expertise is frequently the ability to see what the information does not explicitly tell you.
This philosophy has been central to the development of our proprietary resources at BKREA, including the Knakal Map Room, the Knakal Land Index and our Developer Ranking System. We have invested enormous amounts of time and effort into gathering, organizing and analyzing information about New York City’s investment sales and development markets.
The Land Index, for example, allows us to examine thousands of development site transactions and identify correlations between property characteristics and pricing. Our Map Room helps us visualize development activity, ownership patterns, zoning opportunities and emerging market trends.
These tools provide a tremendous informational advantage, but their greatest value is realized when they are combined with human judgment. A database can identify a pattern. An experienced professional must determine whether that pattern is meaningful, whether it applies to a particular situation, and how it should influence a client’s decision. Technology can make expertise more powerful, but technology and expertise are not interchangeable.
Artificial intelligence is accelerating this transformation. We are moving rapidly toward a world in which access to information will no longer distinguish exceptional professionals from average ones. AI can summarize complex documents, analyze large datasets, generate financial projections, and identify relationships that would have taken teams of analysts weeks to uncover. These capabilities are remarkable, and I believe they will fundamentally change how many industries operate. But there is an important limitation.
Information, regardless of how quickly it is produced, does not automatically become wisdom. Someone still needs to evaluate its reliability, understand its context, challenge its assumptions, and determine the appropriate course of action. This is why I have become increasingly convinced that the value of information is declining while the value of judgment is increasing.
As information becomes more abundant, the ability to interpret it intelligently becomes more valuable. The professionals who thrive will not necessarily be those who possess the most information, but those who know how to use it most effectively.
There is another important characteristic of genuine expertise: the willingness to recognize its limitations. Some of the most knowledgeable people I have encountered throughout my career are also among the quickest to acknowledge what they don’t know. They understand that confidence and certainty are not the same thing. They recognize that markets evolve, assumptions change, and even the most carefully developed conclusions can be wrong. This intellectual humility is not a weakness. It is an essential component of sound judgment.
Expertise should make us more confident in our ability to evaluate complicated situations, but it should never make us unwilling to reconsider our conclusions when new evidence emerges.
The moment expertise becomes an excuse to stop learning, it begins to deteriorate. True experts are not people who have stopped asking questions. They are people whose experience has taught them to ask better ones.
Expertise also carries a responsibility that is sometimes overlooked. The more knowledgeable we become, the greater our opportunity to help others. Throughout my career, mentoring young professionals has been one of my greatest sources of satisfaction. I have watched people who began with very little knowledge of commercial real estate develop into exceptional brokers, business owners and leaders.
Sharing expertise does not diminish its value. It multiplies its impact. When experienced professionals explain not only what they believe, but also why they believe it, they help others develop their own judgment rather than simply memorize someone else’s conclusions.
This is particularly important in an industry where every property is different, every owner has unique objectives, and every market cycle presents new challenges. The objective should never be to create people who merely repeat what we have taught them. It should be to develop professionals capable of thinking independently and eventually seeing things that we ourselves may have missed.
As I reflect on the DNA of Success, I see expertise as the culmination of a process that begins with passion, is sustained by discipline, and is continuously improved through curiosity. But expertise is not the destination. It is a platform from which we can contribute more, lead more effectively, and create greater value for the people who depend on us.
After more than four decades in this business, I am proud of what I have learned, but I am even more excited about what I have yet to discover. My encouragement to anyone seeking to become exceptional at their craft is to develop a genuine love for the work, commit to the consistent effort required to improve, remain endlessly curious, and study every experience for the lessons it contains.
Over time, knowledge becomes understanding, understanding becomes judgment, and judgment becomes the foundation of expertise. But remember that professional mastery, no matter how impressive, is only part of the story. Becoming great at what you do doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve become great at who you are.
And that brings us to the fifth and perhaps most important characteristic in the DNA of Success: becoming.
Robert Knakal is founder, chairman and CEO of BK Real Estate Advisors. This is the fourth column in a five-part series.