Finance  ·  CMBS

Soaring Insurance Premium Costs Permeate CRE Sector


CRED iQ analyzed insurance premiums from 2010 to the first quarter of 2023 with our research aimed at uncovering the trends and drivers behind the rise in insurance costs on commercial real estate properties over recent years. Notably, commercial property insurance premiums experienced a significant increase of 20.4 percent in the first quarter. 

The increasing occurrence and severity of natural disasters continue to be a major worry in the commercial property insurance sector. These catastrophic events frequently lead to substantial property damage and significant financial hardships for policyholders. In just the initial quarter of 2023, the global economy suffered $77 billion in losses due to natural disasters, with insurers covering a third of that cost, amounting to $22 billion.

SEE ALSO: Deutsche Bank Leads $120M Retail Refi for Miami Worldcenter

CRED iQ’s research team measured the magnitude of these insurance premium hikes and pinpointed the top 10 metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs) in the enclosed chart that have witnessed the most substantial increases in premiums for properties on a per unit basis. We have also calculated the historical insurance premium year over year delta again for multifamily on a per unit basis.

Florida stands out as a state where insurance premiums have surged significantly. The heightened exposure in the CRE sector is creating financial difficulties for properties facing upcoming insurance policy renewals and seeking new property financing. This is evident when comparing the five-year percentage change from 2018 to 2022.

CRED iQ has identified a multifamily property in Tampa, Fla., known as The Grand Reserve at Tampa Palms. This property, which comprises 390 units and was constructed in 1999, serves as a prime example of how extreme weather events have led to financial distress over time.

In 2017, according to CRED iQ’s comprehensive financial database, the Tampa Palms property had an insurance premium of approximately $183,000. However, when we examine the fiscal year 2022, the same property incurred a significant increase, with an insurance cost of $521,000. This represents a staggering 185 percent rise, translating to an increase from $469 per unit to $1,336 per unit. 

Some of the factors we examined that lead to insurance premium increases include: 

1. Market Conditions: Changes in overall market dynamics, like shifts in demand for insurance coverage, can influence insurance rates. High demand due to increased risk factors or market trends can lead to rate hikes.

2. Property Location and Risk Assessment: The property’s location plays a vital role in determining insurance rates. Areas prone to natural disasters or higher crime rates typically result in higher premiums.

3. Property Type and Use: The type and intended use of the property affect rates. Properties with more occupants, hazardous materials, or elevated risk features can lead to higher insurance costs.

4. Claims History: Past insurance claims and losses impact future rates. Frequent claims or significant damages in the property’s history can lead to increased premiums.

5. Construction and Building Materials: The quality of construction and materials used affects rates. Older properties or those with vulnerable materials might have higher premiums.

6. Legal and Regulatory Factors: Changes in regulations or building codes can impact rates. Local, state or federal shifts in safety standards or insurance requirements can influence costs.

7. Economic Factors: Economic conditions, such as inflation and interest rates, can impact insurance costs. Inflation can raise rebuilding expenses, leading to higher premiums.

8. Trends in Litigation and Liability: An increase in litigation or liability claims in commercial real estate can prompt insurers to raise rates to cover potential payouts.

9. Reinsurance Costs: Insurers use reinsurance to manage large losses. If reinsurance costs rise due to global events, insurers may pass those costs to policyholders.

10. Global Events and Catastrophes: Large-scale events like natural disasters or pandemics can heighten risk and impact insurance rates by affecting the industry’s financial stability.

These expenses are anticipated to continue and could even escalate throughout the remainder of 2023. This is due to the onset of the hurricane season and the ongoing spread of wildfires in the Western U.S. 

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has foreseen the possibility of up to 17 named storms forming during the 2023 Atlantic hurricane season, which spans from June 1 to Nov. 30. Among these storms, nine could potentially transform into hurricanes with winds exceeding 74 mph, and four of them might attain significant strength with winds surpassing 111 mph.

According to the latest information from the National Interagency Fire Center, there have been approximately 20,000 wildfires that have already consumed over 621,000 acres along the West Coast. While this number is lower than the 10-year average, it serves as an indication of another demanding wildfire season in the upcoming months. Climate experts predict that the ongoing patterns of natural disasters will persist, further intensifying the damages associated with them for the foreseeable future.

Consequently, several reinsurers have acted to restrict their willingness to cover these risks or have even withdrawn their coverage entirely, while rates continue to rise. According to data from the industry, reinsurance treaty renewals on Jan. 1 brought some of the most challenging market conditions in many years. The capacity for additional coverage layers reduced by more than 50 percent, and policyholders encountered rate hikes ranging from 40 percent to 100 percent, depending on their vulnerability to catastrophic events. 

A similar trend was observed during renewals on June 1, with capacity tightening further and rate increases ranging from 25 percent to 40 percent. These developments highlight the ongoing cautious approach prevalent within the reinsurance sector.

Harry Blanchard is managing director and head of data and analytics at CRED iQ.