CMBS Loan Backing 123 William Street Enters Special Servicing Amid Owners’ Bankruptcy Risks
American Strategic Investment Company showed doubt in recent filings about staying in business while its Lower Manhattan office property suffers low occupancy
By Andrew Coen November 19, 2026 12:15 pm
reprints
Manhattan’s office market may be in recovery mode, but a 27-story Financial District building is feeling the weight of distress.
A $140 million commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) loan backing 123 William Street entered special servicing after it fell below break-even levels following a steep drop in occupancy, according to a Morningstar Credit alert issued Thursday morning.
The 540,000-square-foot office building had a leasing occupancy of 72 percent as of June 2026 compared to 92 percent when the loan was underwritten under the WFCM 2017-RB1, WFCM 2017-C38 & MSC 2017-H1 conduit deals. The CMBS loan is slated to mature in March 2027.
The struggles with debt tied to 123 William is compounded by the building’s owner, American Strategic Investment Company (ASIC), struggling to stay afloat.
ASIC, which until 2023 was known as New York City REIT, said there was “substantial doubt” about staying in business due to the looming maturity of the 123 William loan, Bisnow reported in August, citing filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Planned Parenthood has been the building’s largest tenant during the entire loan term, encompassing 12 percent of the building’s office space, according to David Putro, Morningstar Credit Analytics’ head of commercial real estate analytics. The 1957-built property is also home to Bisnow’s New York office along with government tenants that include the General Services Administration, New York State Office of General Services and the Social Security Administration.
Putro said up until 2023 the loan’s performance was in line with original underwriting expectations.
“It’s been the past two and half years where occupancy fell from 91 percent to 72 percent, so it’s been a slow bleed of tenants,” Putro said.
ASIC, which is run by Nicholas Schorsch Jr., did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Andrew Coen can be reached at acoen@commercialobserver.com.