Skip to content
  • Leases
    • Industrial
    • Office
    • Retail
    • All Leases
  • Finance
    • Acquisition
    • CMBS
    • Construction
    • Distress
    • Refinance
    • All Finance
  • Sales
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Mixed Use
    • Land
    • Hotels
    • Development Rights
    • All Sales
  • Design + Construction
    • Architecture
    • Construction
    • Infrastructure
    • Policy
    • Urban Planning
    • Neighborhoods
    • All Design + Construction
  • Technology
  • More
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Features
    • Industry
    • Legal
    • Partner Insights
    • Players
    • Research
    • Tenant Talk
    • Transportation
  • Markets
    • Los Angeles
    • New York City
    • Manhattan
    • Brooklyn
    • Queens
    • Bronx
    • National
    • Washington DC
    • South Florida
  • Videos
    • Power Briefing
    • Leasing + Sales Q&A
    • Design + Construction Q&A
    • On-Demand Events
    • All Videos
  • Weekly Issue
  • Events
  • IMPACT
Log In Sign Up My Account Log Out
  • Account Details
  • Email Preferences
  • Member FAQs
  • Logout
Commercial Observer
  • Leases
    • Industrial
    • Office
    • Retail
    • All
  • Finance
    • Acquisition
    • Construction
    • CMBS
    • Distress
    • Refinance
    • All
  • Sales
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Mixed Use
    • Land
    • Hotels
    • Development Rights
    • All
  • Design + Construction
    • Architecture
    • Construction
    • Infrastructure
    • Policy
    • Urban Planning
    • Neighborhoods
    • All
  • Technology
  • More
    • Features
    • Columnists
    • Analysis
    • Research
    • Partner Insights
    • Industry
    • Legal
    • Players
    • Transportation
    • All
  • Markets
    • Los Angeles
    • New York City
    • Manhattan
    • Brooklyn
    • Queens
    • Bronx
    • National
    • Washington DC
    • South Florida
  • Videos
    • Power Briefing
    • Leasing + Sales Q&A
    • Design + Construction Q&A
    • On-Demand Events
    • All Videos
  • Weekly Issue
  • Events
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Reprints
  • Newsletters
  • Power Finance
  • Power 100
  • Owners Magazine
Log In Sign Up My Account Log Out
  • Account Details
  • Email Preferences
  • Member FAQs
  • Logout

© 2023 Observer Media · Terms · Privacy

Presented By: Lehrer Cumming

Delivering on the Promise of Design-Build

By Lehrer Cumming January 13, 2020 11:46 am
reprints
Javits Center, New York City Photo credit: Lendlease Turner


The Office of the New York Governor has embraced the design-build delivery method for construction, and now a number of large projects are proceeding under this approach for agencies such as the New York State Department of Transportation, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, and the Empire State Development Corporation. The largest of these, and one of the few which is a building project, is the $1.6 billion expansion of the Javits Convention Center, which is currently progressing on schedule and within budget.

Although the design-build methodology is a fairly new concept in the New York building market, it has proven quite successful in other locations and looks to become even more popular going forward. With this in mind, it’s worth taking a closer look at this alternative delivery method.

SEE ALSO: Hudson Pacific Set to Build Major South LA Office Complex With Food Incubator

The reason for design-build’s growing acceptance is simple: It offers the opportunity for a fast-track schedule with less risk to the owner, and it encourages the builder to plan ahead to reduce errors, since the design and construction processes are more tightly intertwined. This helps minimize the risk of profit loss. For example, on the Javits Convention Center project, the design-builder was able to demonstrate ingenuity by changing part of the structure of the large truck marshalling facility — which is capable of holding 250 tractor trailers — from steel to concrete while at the same time forgoing a basement level and a very complex foundation, saving both time and money. This type of flexibility would have been much more difficult or even impossible to achieve on a traditional design-bid-build project.

That said, there is no perfect delivery method, and every approach has its challenges.

“Design-build can be effective, but it is not a miracle solution,” said David Thurm, executive vice president at Lehrer Cumming, who worked on the Javits project. “It needs a lot of planning and a new mentality.”

A successful design-build project requires a lot of upfront work by the client and a team to identify and formalize the programmatic, aesthetic and functional expectations of the owner, as well as to establish and maintain equilibrium between being overly prescriptive and leaving too many decisions up to the builder. The creation of a thorough yet balanced basis for design document is critical to the success of any design-build project. For the Javits project, an extended team including Tishman and Lehrer Cumming, who are working together as owner’s representatives — along with an outside group of engineers and subconsultants — created a comprehensive document that codifies the expectations of the owner while still preserving room for creativity on project delivery.

“Design-build isn’t just a different form of contracting,” added Gus Maimis, also an Executive Vice President at Lehrer Cumming who took over for Thurm on the Javits project. “It requires a new perspective of collaboration, innovation, and risk management from the entire team.”

Few builders have directly managed design and engineering firms. A different temperament is needed to engage the design team and create the open dialogue necessary for a successful project. Even though the design and engineering team has no direct relationship with the owner, there needs to be direct, two-way communication, and access to the owner’s team, to ensure that the design meets the owner’s needs.

In markets where the design-build methodology is not fully ingrained in the construction community — like New York, where it is still relatively new — it’s crucial that project owners are properly educated and receive the protection and guidance of firms who can structure all of the contractual relationships correctly, as well as train and mentor those who need it to navigate the new roles specific to the design-build process.

Design-build can be an effective approach to construction for project owners looking to save time and money while reducing risk; but no delivery method is perfect.

“A strong owner’s rep firm with robust experience in design-build makes all the difference,” said Thurm. “To maximize the success of design-build, you must have a deep understanding of the special pressures and challenges that design-build projects present. Only then will your project realize its full potential.”

construction, David Thurum, design, Empire State Development Corporation, Gus Maimis, Javits Convention Center, Lehrer Cumming, New Jersey, New York Governor, New York State Department of Transportation, Port Authority of New York, Sponsored, sponsored-link, Tishman
 
Trending Stories
Features
National

Sunday Summary: Wicked Good Job Numbers, Wicked Small Rate Hikes

Sales  ·  Hotels
Florida

MCR Buys Hilton Hotel Near MIA for $118M

Leases  ·  Industry
New York City

Manhattan Office Leasing Notches Highest Total Since 2019: Report

Sales  ·  Land
Florida

Terra Under Contract for Midtown Miami Site

Perkins & Will will design the project for the 5.7-acre site.
Design + Construction  ·  Development
Los Angeles

Hudson Pacific Set to Build Major South LA Office Complex With Food Incubator

By Greg Cornfield
Samson Stage's new studio project at 744 Clinton Street will include public green space.
Design + Construction  ·  Architecture
New York City

New Movie Studio Coming to Red Hook Waterfront

By Rebecca Baird-Remba
100 Flatbush Avenue tops out by the Barclays Center.
Design + Construction  ·  Architecture
New York City

All-Electric Skyscraper at 100 Flatbush Avenue Inches Toward Finish Line

By Rebecca Baird-Remba

  • Leases
    • Industrial
    • Retail
    • Office
  • Finance
    • Acquisition
    • Construction
    • CMBS
    • Distress
    • Refinance
  • Sales
    • Residential
    • Commercial
    • Mixed Use
    • Land
    • Hotels
    • Development Rights
  • Design + Construction
    • Architecture
    • Construction
    • Infrastructure
    • Policy
    • Urban Planning
    • Neighborhoods
  • Technology
  • More
    • Features
    • Columnists
    • Analysis
    • Research
    • Industry
    • Legal
    • Players
    • Transportation
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Newsletters
    • Contact
    • Reprints

Read the latest edition of the Commercial Observer online!

July 28th 2020 Magazine Issue Cover
© 2023 Observer Media Terms Privacy Cookie Settings Do not sell my data Sitemap