Wells Fargo Sets Defeasance Record
Damian Ghigliotty March 4, 2015, 10:10 a.m.
With the defeasance sector heating back up, as more borrowers look to replace their CMBS loans with U.S. Treasuries to lock in low interest rates, Wells Fargo set an eyebrow-raising record last year.
The banking giant, which ranks as the nation’s largest commercial loan servicer, defeased $11.8 billion in securitized debt in 2014, equal to the amount of total defeasance throughout the U.S. the previous year, a Wells Fargo executive told Mortgage Observer.
The San Francisco-based firm’s overall defeasance activity grew more than 100 percent from $5.8 billion in 2013 and more than 280 percent from $3.1 billion in 2012. The bank’s activity last year accounted for 61 percent of all defeased debt in the U.S., which hit a post-crisis record of $19 billion among 1,230 loans in 2014.
Wells Fargo’s director of defeasance management, Lillian Fahr, attributes that hefty growth to rising property values, sustained low interest rates, and the willingness of lenders to “get back out there and lend.” Going forward, the bank is well poised to take an even larger chunk of the defeasance pie, she said.
“We’re hitting the years of peak maturities that date back to 2005, 6 and 7, so we expect our defeasance business to continue growing in 2015, 16 and 17,” Ms. Fahr, based in Charlotte, N.C., told MO. “We project 25 to 30 percent growth from 2014 to 2015 and expect that trend to continue in the next two years.”
Total defeasance volume in the U.S. in 2014 rose 61 percent to $19 billion from $11.8 billion in 2013, data from the New York-based research firm Trepp shows. That number is still down from a pre-crisis high of $34 billion in 2007.
Wells Fargo, which has acted as both servicer and consultant in the defeasance industry since late 2004, has also grown its defeasance consulting business in the past year to roughly 25 percent of the market—edging out most of the bank’s competitors in that arena. Those 15 or so firms include Charlotte-based Commercial Defeasance, Kennett Square, Pa.-based Chatham Financial, and Los Angles-based AST Defeasance Services, according to industry data.
“We compete with Wells often and they give us a run,” said Eitan Weinstock, senior analyst at AST Defeasance. “As servicer for a large percentage of loans in the industry, they are involved on a great many defeasances.”
Still, rising competition and a potential slowdown in defeasance activity—dependent on future changes in interest rates—are two concerns for Ms. Fahr and her team.
“Right now people are rushing to defease because of where interest rates are,” Ms. Fahr said. “If there is a clear sign that interest rates may go even lower, borrowers may say, ‘Well then I can wait another six months or another year.’ ”
If interest rates were to increase significantly, that would have a more severe impact on the business, she said.
For the time being, with rates hovering around 4 percent and under, Wells Fargo is looking to further grow its defeasance consulting to as much as 65 percent of all defeased debt serviced by the bank. In 2014, that business made up less than half of the Wells Fargo defeasance activity, with Ms. Fahr’s team serving as consultant on 314 of the 714 loans that the bank defeased.
Mr. Weinstock said many of his firm’s clients come to AST to ensure that they have an outside consultant working with Wells Fargo and other commercial mortgage servicers. (The second and third largest are PNC Real Estate/Midland Loan Services and Berkadia Commercial Mortgage, according to data from the Mortgage Bankers Association.) At the same time, he acknowledged Wells Fargo’s “unique ability to act as both consultant and master servicer” on defeasance transactions. “That is something no other servicer has done,” Mr. Weinstock said.
The two largest deals Wells Fargo defeased last year were a $475 million loan on Tishman Speyer’s office tower at 520 Madison Avenue and a $420 million loan on Paramount Group’s office tower at 1301 Avenue of the Americas, according to Ms. Fahr. The largest defeasance that the bank served as both consultant and servicer on was a $195 million loan for Hartz Mountain Industries’ Tribeca Grand Hotel.
“A big part of my role is to let borrowers know that we do the consultancy work in addition to the servicing work,” said the Wells Fargo executive, who joined the bank through its 2008 acquisition of Wachovia. “As the largest master servicer, we are putting more focus on the consultant services where there hadn’t been as much attention on that part of the business in the past.”